-
A
Requesting additional medical records before settling a large injury claim
-
B
Deliberately delaying payment of an undisputed, valid claim for 9 months with no legitimate reason, forcing the claimant to accept a lower settlement out of financial desperation
-
C
Negotiating a lower settlement than the claimant demanded
-
D
Denying a claim for a valid coverage exclusion with a written explanation
Why this is the answer
BAD FAITH in insurance claims handling refers to an insurer's breach of its implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing — an obligation all insurers owe to their insureds (and in some states, to third-party claimants). BAD FAITH EXAMPLES — conduct that is clearly actionable: UNREASONABLE DELAY: deliberately stalling payment of a valid, undisputed claim (as in the scenario) without any legitimate reason; claimants often accept reduced settlements out of financial desperation after long delays — using delay as a settlement tactic is a classic bad faith pattern; MISREPRESENTING COVERAGE: telling a claimant a loss isn't covered when it clearly is; FAILING TO INVESTIGATE: settling without reasonable investigation or denying without proper investigation; LOWBALLING: making settlement offers the insurer knows are far below the actual value of the claim without reasonable justification; FAILING TO SETTLE WITHIN POLICY LIMITS: when a case clearly exceeds policy limits and a settlement demand is made within limits, failure to settle can expose the insurer to an excess judgment against the insured (bad faith toward the insured); REFUSING TO COMMUNICATE: ignoring calls and correspondence; THREATS AND COERCION: pressuring claimants to accept inadequate settlements. NOT BAD FAITH: REQUESTING ADDITIONAL RECORDS: legitimate investigation is expected and required; NEGOTIATING: offering less than demanded, if based on reasonable evaluation; DENYING FOR A VALID EXCLUSION: with a clear, written, policy-supported explanation. BAD FAITH CONSEQUENCES: insurance companies can be liable for: the original claim amount; consequential damages (beyond the policy limit in some cases); attorney's fees; PUNITIVE DAMAGES (in egregious cases, potentially multiples of actual damages); regulatory action and license consequences.
Source: Insurance Adjuster, Bad Faith Claims Handling