3. A broker advertises a property as 'lakefront' when in fact it is set back from the lake with neighboring lots between. What is the typical legal characterization?
-
A
Acceptable creative description
-
B
MISREPRESENTATION — a violation of state license law, potentially fair housing law if discriminatory, and grounds for civil liability for damages; advertising must be truthful and not misleading
-
C
Buyer beware applies
-
D
Common practice
Explanation
Real estate advertising must be TRUTHFUL and NOT MISLEADING. This applies whether the misrepresentation is express (clearly stating something false) or by implication (suggesting something that is not true). MATERIAL FACT MISREPRESENTATIONS include: (1) Property characteristics (waterfront, acreage, square footage, lot size, year built, finished basement, age of systems); (2) Property condition (no flooding, no structural issues, recent renovation); (3) Property history (no deaths on property, no environmental issues); (4) Zoning, permits, easements; (5) Schools, school district, neighborhood character; (6) Tax information; (7) HOA fees and rules. LEVEL OF KNOWLEDGE: (1) ACTUAL KNOWLEDGE — The agent KNOWS the statement is false: clear violation, often fraudulent; (2) CONSTRUCTIVE KNOWLEDGE — The agent SHOULD have known by reasonable investigation (this is the level expected of professionals); (3) NEGLIGENCE — The agent failed to verify before making the claim. Many states require agents to: (1) Verify material claims before advertising; (2) Use only information confirmed by the seller or public records; (3) Avoid puffery that crosses into misrepresentation; (4) Distinguish opinion (puffery) from fact statements. PUFFERY vs MISREPRESENTATION: 'BEAUTIFUL HOME' is puffery (opinion); 'LAKEFRONT' is a factual claim. 'LAKE ACCESS' may also be misleading if access is not actually granted or convenient. 'WALKING DISTANCE TO SCHOOL' is borderline — what's walking distance? Better to use specific distance. Avoid: 'gourmet kitchen' if no special features; 'master suite' if it's just a bedroom; 'finished basement' if not actually finished; 'recently renovated' if it was 10 years ago; 'newer roof' if it's 12 years old. STATE REMEDIES: (1) Commission complaint → fine, suspension, revocation; (2) Civil lawsuit by buyer who relied → rescission of contract, damages, attorney's fees; (3) Federal: misrepresenting in interstate commerce can be wire fraud or mail fraud. FAIR HOUSING: Some misrepresentations may also violate Fair Housing Act if used to discourage or steer based on protected classes. ADVERTISING REVIEW: Brokers should have a written policy that ALL advertising claims must be verified before publication. Key factual claims should be supported by: seller's written disclosure, public records, professional survey, contractor invoices for renovations, etc. NUANCED CASES: (1) 'WATER VIEW' — yes, if you can see water; 'WATERFRONT' — only if directly on the water; 'WATER ACCESS' — only if access is genuine; (2) 'GREAT SCHOOLS' — refer to actual ratings; (3) 'QUIET NEIGHBORHOOD' — could vary; 'NO HOA' — must be true; 'LOW TAXES' — relative; (4) 'NEW ROOF' — specify when; 'UPDATED KITCHEN' — when. DOCUMENT all factual claims in the listing file with source.
Source: Misrepresentation in Advertising